Some people practice a form of vegetariansim called veganism. The definition of vegan can be different from person to person, but generally it means that one does not consume or use animal products in which an animal was harmed to obtain them.
Unfertilized eggs can’t develop into a chick. Because of this, some vegans will eat chicken and quail eggs that are certified unfertilized. Now for a potential problem – chickens, quails, turkeys, and other birds are known to undergo parthenogenesis! Unfertilized eggs might have a partially developed embryo inside them. What is a vegan to do?!
The thought that birds might be able to undergo parthenogenesis is not that strange. Reptiles are the ancestors of bird species, and reptiles are famous for their number of parthenogenic species, both obligate and facultative.
The difference between parthenogenesis in birds and in reptiles is that the bird form rarely, very rarely, ends with a chick hatching from the egg. Most die at some point in development - usually early.
The first species in which bird parthenogenesis was studied was the Beltsville Small White (BSW) Turkey. It was recognized in the 1950’s that this breed had some eggs that had started to develop even though they had not been mated to a male.
The researchers then embarked on a long breeding project in which they increased the number of parthenogenic embryos. By breeding females that had a higher tendency to lay parthenogenic eggs to males from mothers who were more likely to develop parthenogenic eggs, the scientists developed the breed for parthenogens that developed longer and longer.
In some cases (still less than 1%) the parthenogenic eggs would hatch. And some of those turkeys matured fully and lived to a ripe old age! The breed still exists and is still studied, so parthenogenic tom turkeys are born to these females every once in a while.
After studies in turkeys were publicized, it was recognized that parthenogenic development was also occurring in chickens. There was a single report of parthenogenesis in a pigeon. Then in the late 2000’s, parthenogenesis in both Chinese Painted Quails and Zebra Finches was recognized. It is important to note that in these later named species, only one parthenogen was noted to survive; that being a chicken in the 1970’s. At that time, molecular methods of genome identification were not available, so we are not sure if this was a true parthenogen.
The other point to note is that these are all domesticated, captive birds. We don’t know if parthenogenesis takes place in birds in the wild. Similar to the cases in other animals, we first recognized parthenogenesis in sharks and komodo dragons in zoos, because that is where people could control if females were exposed to males. Many assumed that parthenogenesis was caused by a lack of males and that they would not give birth from unfertilized eggs in the wild. We now know that isn’t true for komodos, and we have the report showing that pit vipers will undergo parthenogenesis in the wild, even if males are present. Who knows if this is the case for birds.
To understand parthenogenesis in birds, it would help to look at how eggs are produced; we’ll use the chicken as a model. Some weird things can happen with chicken eggs and their process of production is responsible for most of these oddities.
If the human egg is fertilized, the embryo will implant into the wall of the uterus and the placenta will develop. If not, the uterine environment will flush itself out each month and the cycle will begin again. This is different in chickens. Whether the egg is fertilized or not, the ovum (and attached yolk) will be sent on along the oviduct and an egg will be formed.
Chicks are born with 13,000-14,000 ova and they produce no more. Not all will be laid as eggs, but every 26 hours or so, a new ovum with developed yolk (fatty nutrients for the developing chick) will be released from the ovary. The timing of the release is actually controlled by the laying of the egg. When an egg is laid, a new ovum will be released about 30-60 minutes later.
Ovulation is also controlled by the amount of sunlight in the day. Summer day lengths stimulate ovulation, so egg producers manipulate the lights so the hens always think it is summer.
Of course, there is an exception to this. Chickens won’t ovulate after about 3:00 pm! They must where watches. And the entire process for laying an egg takes about 26 hours. This is longer than a day – duh - so each day the chicken will ovulate about 2 hours later. This keeps up until she would be due to ovulate after 3:00. In this case, she just won’t do it, and will wait until the next morning to ovulate. As a result, a chicken will not lay an egg once every six days or so.
After the magnum is the isthmus. This is where the egg is surrounded by the inner and outer membranes. The next stop is the shell gland, and you can guess what is added here. The calcium carbonate shell takes about 20 hours to form around the egg, so this is where the egg spends the majority of its time. Then it is laid by being squeezed out with muscle movement.
Like I mentioned above, weird things can happen during this 25-27 inch trek through the chicken. Sometimes two ova may be released at once. These can both be surrounded by a single albumen and shell and come out as a double yolk egg. There are instances where one or both yolks may be fertilized, but the lack of space and nutrients usually leads to at least one of the chicks dying in the shell, and usually both. The record is nine yolks in a single egg!
On a different note, when the hen is young no ovum may be released, and a small piece of loose tissue could be mistaken for an ovum. In this case, it will be wrapped in albumen, membranes and shell, and a yolkless egg will be produced. I have a student who is seriously considering investigating a way to manipulate chickens to give yolkless eggs all the time – could be a million dollar idea.
There was a recent story that illustrated one more weird possibility. If the muscular movement shoots the egg backward instead of out, it can happen that the developed egg will go through another round of the process. It can also meet up with the next developing ovum. In this case, the developed egg could be surrounded with more albumen, membrane, and then be wrapped in another shell - an egg within an egg! Don’t believe me?
In parthenogenesis, the ovum + yolk will be diploid, the result of endomitosis or fusion of two ova. They will be sent along the path of egg production, and once laid, they look like regular eggs. The embryo will not develop beyond three days or so, so they are hard to tell from unfertilized eggs or those eggs that are fertilized and undergo spontaneous early embryonic death. You probably wouldn’t know if you were eating one.
In the BSW turkeys, breeding led to later development and finally some live hatchings. This is now being tried in quails as well. Dr. C.D. McDaniel at Mississippi State University is investigating the idea that parthenogenic development actually reduces the hen’s ability to hatch fertilized eggs.
After nine generations of cross breeding females and males to increase parthenogenic development, that quail that have more parthenogenic events do indeed have fewer fertilized eggs that hatch and develop to mature quails. Late embryonic death decreased, but early death increased dramatically. This is a significant economic question, as it would seem that lower rates of parthenogenesis will lead to greater production of quails.
Next week, we will see that parthenogenesis is not always the “choice” of the female. Sometimes, parthenogenesis can be forced on an animal.